Introducing Financial Audit Bench Read the post →

Nonprofit Audit Committee: Do You Need One and What Should It Do?

men and women in a fun run activity

Not every nonprofit is legally required to have a nonprofit audit committee, but most organizations above a certain revenue threshold should have one anyway. An audit committee provides independent oversight of the external audit process, financial reporting, and internal controls, and it signals to donors, grantors, and regulators that a board takes its fiduciary duties seriously. Whether you are building one from scratch or strengthening an existing committee, understanding what the rules require and what best practice looks like will save your organization from common governance pitfalls.

When Is a Nonprofit Audit Committee Required?

There is no federal law that universally mandates a nonprofit audit committee. The IRS does not require one as a condition of tax-exempt status. Form 990 Part VI does ask whether an organization that had its financials audited or reviewed has a committee responsible for oversight of that process and for selecting the independent accountant, but that question is informational, not a legal mandate. The real requirements come from state law and, in some cases, grant conditions.

State-by-State Mandates

State attorneys general and charitable registration statutes are the primary source of audit committee obligations for nonprofits. Two states with explicit requirements are California and New York.

California. The Nonprofit Integrity Act of 2004 requires any charitable organization with $2 million or more in gross revenue to have an independent audit committee. The committee must be separate from the finance committee, must recommend hiring and terminating the auditor, and must review audit scope and results. Staff members, the president or CEO, and the treasurer or CFO cannot serve on the committee, finance committee members cannot make up 50 percent or more of the audit committee, and the audit committee chair cannot be a member of the finance committee. The requirement applies for any fiscal year in which the organization accrues $2 million or more in gross revenue, excluding government grants for which the nonprofit must account for how the funds are used.

New York. The New York Nonprofit Revitalization Act requires that any charitable organization with annual revenue of $1 million or more have either its full board or a designated audit committee comprised solely of independent directors oversee financial reporting and audit processes. The organization’s independent audit must also be reviewed by this committee or the full board before the return is filed. The New York Attorney General’s Charities Bureau has published detailed guidance on these obligations.

Other states have similar, though less detailed, governance expectations built into their charitable registration requirements. The National Council of Nonprofits maintains a state-by-state overview of audit requirements that is worth reviewing if you operate or solicit donations across multiple states.

Federal Award Recipients

Nonprofits that expend $1,000,000 or more in federal awards in a fiscal year are subject to a Single Audit under 2 CFR Part 200. That threshold increased from $750,000 to $1,000,000 for fiscal years beginning on or after October 1, 2024. While the Uniform Guidance does not directly mandate an audit committee, federal awarding agencies and pass-through entities generally expect grantees to have adequate oversight structures in place. An audit committee is the most visible way to demonstrate that oversight exists.

When No Law Requires One, Best Practice Still Does

If you fall below the California or New York thresholds and do not receive federal awards, you are likely not legally required to form an audit committee. Even so, the AICPA’s Audit Committee Toolkit for Not-for-Profit Entities recommends that organizations of all sizes consider establishing one. Foundations, major donors, and government grantors often look for an audit committee as a marker of financial maturity. A smaller organization that proactively builds one demonstrates a level of governance sophistication that strengthens credibility and helps attract funding.

What a Nonprofit Audit Committee Actually Does

The audit committee’s job is oversight, not management. It does not prepare financial statements, conduct the audit, or run day-to-day accounting operations. Its function is to sit between the board and the external auditor, protecting the integrity of financial reporting.

Core Responsibilities

A well-functioning nonprofit audit committee typically handles the following:

  • Auditor selection and oversight. The committee recommends the independent auditor to the full board, negotiates the engagement letter and fee, and evaluates auditor performance year over year. It also oversees the auditor’s independence, which means monitoring whether the auditing firm provides any non-audit services that could create a conflict.
  • Pre-audit planning. Before fieldwork begins, the committee meets with the auditor to review the planned scope, materiality thresholds, and any areas of significant risk. This conversation gives the committee a chance to raise concerns and ensures the audit is properly calibrated to the organization’s complexity.
  • Review of results. After the audit, the committee reviews the audited financial statements, the management letter (if issued), any required communications from the auditor under auditing standards, and any adjustments proposed or recorded during the engagement.
  • Internal controls monitoring. The committee keeps an eye on the design and effectiveness of internal controls over financial reporting. If the auditor identifies a material weakness or significant deficiency, the committee tracks management’s remediation plan.
  • Fraud risk awareness. The committee creates a channel for the external auditor, internal staff, or whistleblowers to raise concerns about potential fraud or financial misconduct. Many organizations route ethics hotline reports to the audit committee chair rather than management to preserve independence.
  • Form 990 review. Before the return is filed, the audit committee (or full board, depending on the organization’s policy) reviews the Form 990 for accuracy and consistency with audited financials.

Relationship to the Full Board

The audit committee reports to the full board, not to management. Its findings, concerns, and recommendations are presented at board meetings. This reporting line is critical: if the committee reported to the CFO or executive director, its independence would be compromised from the start. The board retains ultimate fiduciary responsibility, but the audit committee provides the depth of focus on financial matters that a full board meeting cannot realistically deliver.

Building a Strong Audit Committee

Composition and Independence

Independence is the non-negotiable foundation. Every member should be free from material financial relationships with the organization other than serving as a volunteer director. Staff, officers, and anyone with a financial interest in a significant vendor or contractor should not serve.

The AICPA recommends a minimum of 3 independent members, with best practice leaning toward 4. At least one member should qualify as a financial expert, defined as someone with experience as a CFO, controller, public accountant, or auditor, or with equivalent supervisory experience over such roles. That person does not have to be a CPA, but they do need genuine fluency with GAAP financial statements and the audit process. The rest of the committee does not need the same technical depth, but they should be capable of asking good questions and understanding the answers.

Nonprofit board members who also serve on the finance committee can sit on the audit committee in most states, with the exception of California, which limits their proportion to less than 50 percent of the committee’s membership.

The Audit Committee Charter

Every audit committee should operate under a written charter. The charter is the governing document that defines the committee’s purpose, membership requirements, meeting frequency, scope of authority, and relationship to the board and management. It should be approved by the full board and reviewed annually.

An audit committee charter for a nonprofit typically covers:

  • Mission and authority. Why the committee exists and what it is empowered to do (for example, the authority to retain outside advisors independently of management).
  • Composition. Minimum number of members, independence criteria, and financial expert requirement.
  • Responsibilities. A detailed list of the functions described in the section above.
  • Meeting requirements. How often the committee meets, whether it meets privately with the external auditor (without management present), and quorum rules.
  • Reporting. How and when the committee reports to the full board.

The AICPA publishes a sample not-for-profit audit committee charter matrix that organizations can adapt. It is a useful starting point, particularly for smaller organizations that are building governance infrastructure for the first time.

Meeting Cadence and Private Sessions

Most nonprofit audit committees meet at least twice a year: once before the audit begins and once after the draft report is available. Organizations with more complex finances, multiple funding streams, or federal awards may meet quarterly.

One practice that is easy to skip but worth keeping: an executive session with the external auditor, without any staff or management present. This gives the auditor a private channel to share concerns that might be difficult to raise in a management-attended meeting. Auditing standards encourage this kind of direct access, and a well-governed audit committee builds it into its calendar as a standing agenda item.

How Audit Committee Oversight Connects to the External Audit

When an organization has a functioning audit committee, the relationship with the external auditor works differently than when the committee is absent or dormant. Under professional auditing standards, the auditor is required to communicate certain matters directly to those charged with governance, which generally means the audit committee or the full board. These required communications include significant findings from the audit, auditor independence, the auditor’s views on qualitative aspects of accounting policies, and any significant difficulties encountered during the engagement.

A committee that understands these communications and asks substantive questions gives the auditing team useful feedback and helps management prioritize post-audit action items. An audit committee that meets once a year to rubber-stamp the engagement letter and sign the management representation letter is not providing the oversight it was formed to provide.

If you are working through an audit engagement and want to understand how oversight structures interact with audit scope and findings, the team at Modus can walk you through the process before fieldwork begins.

What Can Go Wrong Without One

Operating without a functioning audit committee creates real governance and financial risks:

  • Auditor capture. When management selects and communicates exclusively with the auditor, there is no independent check on that relationship. Auditors are professionals and have their own standards of independence, but a board-level oversight function adds an important structural safeguard.
  • Missed red flags. An auditor may flag a concern in the management letter or in required communications that quietly disappears because no one at the board level is tracking the follow-up.
  • Grantor scrutiny. Foundation program officers and government grants administrators increasingly ask about governance structure during due diligence. An organization without an audit committee may face harder questions or a more cautious funding decision.
  • Regulatory exposure. In California and New York, failing to maintain a compliant audit committee can lead to penalties, required corrective action, or loss of charitable registration in good standing.

For organizations subject to a Single Audit, the expectations of federal oversight and pass-through entity monitoring create additional accountability pressure. Learn more about how Modus approaches nonprofit audit and assurance engagements.

Frequently Asked Questions

Should a nonprofit have an audit committee?

Most nonprofits that undergo an independent audit benefit from having an audit committee. It is legally required in California for organizations with $2 million or more in gross revenue and in New York for organizations with $1 million or more in annual revenue. Even where not required, an audit committee improves oversight, strengthens auditor independence, and signals financial maturity to donors and grantors.

What is the difference between an audit committee and a finance committee?

A finance committee typically helps the board oversee budgeting, cash management, investments, and financial planning. An audit committee focuses specifically on the integrity of financial reporting, the external audit relationship, and internal controls. California law explicitly requires these to be separate. In practice, the two committees may share members, but the audit committee must maintain its independence from management and from any operational financial decisions.

How many members should a nonprofit audit committee have?

Best practice, including guidance from the AICPA, calls for a minimum of 3 independent members. A committee of 4 is often more practical to ensure a quorum and allow for reasonable turnover. At least one member should have financial expertise, defined as substantial experience as a CFO, controller, accountant, or auditor.

What goes in a nonprofit audit committee charter?

An audit committee charter should cover the committee’s purpose and authority, membership and independence requirements, core responsibilities (auditor selection, pre-audit planning, results review, internal controls, fraud risk), meeting frequency, executive session practices, and how the committee reports to the full board. The AICPA publishes a sample charter matrix that nonprofits can adapt for their size and complexity.

Does the audit committee have to approve the Form 990?

There is no universal federal requirement that the audit committee approve Form 990. New York’s Nonprofit Revitalization Act does require that the return be reviewed by the audit committee or full board before filing for organizations subject to its provisions. Beyond legal requirements, it is a governance best practice for the audit committee to review the Form 990 for consistency with the audited financials before it is submitted.

Can staff members serve on the nonprofit audit committee?

No. Staff members, officers, the CEO, and the CFO should not serve on the audit committee. Independence from management is the committee’s defining characteristic. Any member with a material financial relationship to the organization other than board service is disqualified from serving. California’s Nonprofit Integrity Act codifies this explicitly, and it reflects the broader standard applied in every credible governance framework.

Filed under: Nonprofit Audits Nonprofit